A Brief History of Rocky River Presbyterian Church

Rocky River Presbyterian Church is a vibrant, growing congregation that is proud of and willing to learn from its rich history. Since celebrating our 250th anniversary in 2001, we have turned our energy toward an exciting future as we seek God’s plan for us in our rapidly growing community.


In order to appreciate where Rocky River Church is today, it is important to know a little about her history.


Rocky River Presbyterian Church was started in the home of William White, Sr. in 1751. It is first mentioned in the official records of the New Side Synod of New York in October of 1755. The first pastor, the Rev. Alexander Craighead, was installed on November 6, 1758. Mr. Craighead was very outspoken in his views against the British dating back to the 1730s. No doubt he inspired the local colonists in a spirit which led to the Mecklenburg Declaration of Independence on May 20, 1775. Unfortunately, Mr. Craighead died without seeing the formation of the United States of America. Rocky River’s second pastor, the Rev. Hezekiah James Balch, was instrumental in writing the Mecklenburg Declaration of Independence and the May 31, 1775, Mecklenburg Resolves.


Original sanctuary

The site of the original log sanctuary lies some two miles to the northwest of the present one. This site is now within Pharr Mill Road Park. The second sanctuary, also of logs, was erected about 1776 and was situated several hundred yards to the east of the current church. The third sanctuary, dating from 1807, was of frame construction and occupied ground now included in the cemetery to the rear of the present church.

Present Sanctuary

The present and fourth sanctuary was dedicated in 1861 and was built at a cost of $6,000. The sanctuary had a seating capacity of 750, when it was built. The last extensive work inside was done in 1969 when the ceiling was replaced after the partial collapse of the original plaster one. The exterior brick work was restored in 1974 to preserve its appearance. Fingerprints can be seen in the handmade bricks. The Wilcox Educational Building was dedicated in 1949.


The balcony of the sanctuary was designed for occupancy by the slaves who attended Rocky River. The church’s membership peaked in 1856 with 448 white and 202 African American members. Although most of the former slaves organized Bellefonte Presbyterian Church in 1867, some continued as members of Rocky River until the mid-1870s.

Session house

The frame Session House dates from 1839. In 2001, the Session House became a simple prayer chapel offering people a quiet place to pray and meditate.

May Meeting

What is May Meeting? How did it begin?


Sunday, May 7, 2017 is a special day at Rocky River Presbyterian Church, and we invite you to come  and worship and eat dinner with us. It is our annual “May Meeting.” Don’t worry – it’s not a “meeting.”


May Meeting evolved over the years and is a variation of a tradition the early settlers brought from the Church of Scotland. In the earliest days of our congregation, when there was not a full-time minister, the Synods of New York or Philadelphia sent Presbyterian ministers to churches in the backwoods of North Carolina in the spring and in the fall to hold the sacrament of communion and to baptize children and  adults since these sacraments could only be performed by an ordained minister. It seems that the spring communion service has always been the first Sunday in May. The fall communion service has moved around to different dates. September Meeting is now the second Sunday in September. 


May Meeting begins with Sunday School classes for all ages at 10 am. The worship service at 11 am  includes communion. During the early days of our church, which was organized in 1751, the sacrament of communion was not observed as often as it is today. There was a seriousness associated with this sacrament. Prior to May Meeting Sunday, there were Preparatory Services each evening for a week to prepare the hearts of the members for the Lord’s Supper. For many years the Scottish tradition of giving

those who had attended the services a token which they would turn in on the Sunday morning of May  Meeting in order to receive communion. The theory was that only those who had attended the Preparatory Services were mentally and spiritually ready to receive communion. For much of the twentieth century, there were Preparatory Services on the Thursday and Friday evenings prior to May Meeting. No tokens were distributed or required on Sunday, but it harkened back to this earlier tradition. Due to decreased attendance, the Preparatory Services were discontinued some time ago.


Dinner in the Grove around two long wire tables between the sanctuary and playground follows the worship service. Folks bring favorite foods to share along the table. There is no organization to the food. Each family just puts all the foods they bring together on the table so they can find their empty dishes later! Plates, utensils and napkins are scattered along the length of the table so there is no specific starting place. You can just peek in and see something you want to eat, ask the person closest to the table to let you jump  in and get what you want, then move out. Or you can walk down the length of the table and find what you want to eat. Tea, water, juice, lemonade, colas that folks bring are placed on a table where ice and cups are available. 


For many years, families ate together whatever food their group brought. Different families staked  out specific areas of the grove and returned to those family spaces year after year. In 1949, the Wilcox Education Building was dedicated at May Meeting. This was a long-awaited event, so the Women of the Church organized everyone coming together to gather around a single long table instead of splitting up into family groups. It was such a success and so much fun being together that the current tradition we enjoy was born.


May Meeting has always been a time for special events at our church. For many years,  babies were baptized at May Meeting. Records from the 1800s show that some years there were over thirty children baptized and many people united with the church at May Meeting. The current sanctuary was dedicated at May Meeting in 1861. As noted above, the Wilcox Education Building was dedicated in 1949. In 2013, the ground-breaking for the new education building was at May Meeting and that building was

dedicated on May Meeting in 2014.


The spring down the hill from the playground is owned by the McCachren family. When Rocky River  Presbyterian Church built its third sanctuary in what is now the cemetery behind the current (4th) sanctuary, the McCachren family gave the congregation use of the spring as long as there is a church at this location. Families in those early days got water from the spring to have with their May Meeting meals. Walking down the hill on those wide steps to the spring was a May Meeting tradition for children and families for many years – and possibly still is a tradition for some.


Until around 1980, there was also a worship service about 1:30 on the afternoon of May Meeting.  Again, a decrease in attendance led to the demise of this tradition. This service probably started when families coming from long distances who maybe did not get to worship services every week wanted the opportunity to worship a second time on that special day.


The roots of May Meeting go very deep at Rocky River Presbyterian Church. It is one of the traditions that is unique to our congregation. May Meeting has evolved over the years to the special Sunday we now know, but it has always been a special time that draws those who love this church back year after year. There are people who come back “home” to Rocky River every May Meeting. Others who have only heard of our church through family stories often develop a new tradition of coming to May Meeting to feel a kinship with past generations of their families. Many families end the day with a walk in the cemetery. At

May Meeting more than any other Sunday, the connection is felt to earlier members of our church and the  “cloud of witnesses” who have sat in those same pews we now occupy.

Section Title

Type the content for this section here. This is just example text to show you what it will look like when you enter text content into this section. Your unique, authentic, and appropriate text will be filled into this section.


Once you click into this section, you will see the filler text disappear, and you can begin typing your real content. We’ve simply put in filler text in this area. No need to get caught up in the actual content of this body text, we just typed a bunch of meaningless sentences. If you get anything from this text, please understand that this is just example text to give you a feeling for what your real text might look like.